What regulatory systems do not do
Although regulatory systems for research impose onerous requirements on researchers before studies start, there are many things they conspicuously fail to do, or do not do well.
What research regulation should do
“If ethicists and others want something to criticise in clinical trials, they should look at scientifically inadequate work, reinvention of wheels, and above all, unjustifiable exclusions and unjust and irrational uses of resources.”
Moreover, most of the effort in regulating research is at the start-up stage, with the emphasis on controlling the entry of participants to studies. But there is surprisingly little effort devoted to monitoring studies once they are running, and to ensuring that researchers publish reports promptly at the end of their work (or even at all), stating how their findings have reduced uncertainty.
People who are invited to participate in research on the effects of treatments need to have confidence that the studies are worthwhile, and that their contributions will be useful. Regulatory systems need to do more to reassure them on both counts and dismantle needless barriers to good research directed towards research questions that matter to patients.
There is a growing realization that testing treatments is everybody’s business. As patients and the public take up the opportunities now being offered to become involved in planning and conducting research, they are likely to have an increasing voice in ensuring that regulatory obstacles are addressed.
Review of the Key points
- Regulation of research is unnecessarily complex
- Current systems of research regulation discourage fair tests of treatments that would make for better healthcare
- Despite the onerous regulatory requirements placed on researchers, regulatory systems do little to ensure that proposed studies are genuinely needed
- Research regulation does little to monitor and followup approved research
More: References (Section 9)
Next Chapter: Research – good, bad and unnecessary
GET-IT Jargon Buster
GET-IT provides plain language definitions of health research terms